Nadaaniyan: Ibrahim Ali Khan Shares Film Ratings Again After Fan Deletes One-Star Reviews
Ibrahim Ali Khan shares ratings for Nadaaniyan again after a fan deletes one-star reviews. Find out why he’s speaking up!
Ibrahim Ali Khan, son of Bollywood actors Saif Ali Khan and Amrita Singh, recently made his acting debut in the Netflix film “Nadaaniyan ,” co-starring Khushi Kapoor. The film, produced by Dharmatic Entertainment, has garnered attention not only for its star-studded lineage but also for the controversy surrounding its audience ratings.
Despite the initial buzz, “Nadaaniyan ” has faced criticism from both critics and viewers, leading to a rather underwhelming reception.
The Plot of “Nadaaniyan”
“Nadaaniyan ” is a romantic drama that explores the complexities of modern relationships among the youth. The narrative centers around Pia Jai Singh (Khushi Kapoor), a privileged student at Falcon High, and Arjun Mehta (Ibrahim Ali Khan), a new transfer from a modest background.
After a misunderstanding with her friends, Pia concocts a plan to hire Arjun to pose as her boyfriend on social media, leading to a series of events that challenge their perceptions of love and societal expectations. The film attempts to delve into themes of class disparity, friendship, and the facade of social media personas.
Critical Reception
Upon its release on March 7, 2025, “Nadaaniyan ” received predominantly negative reviews from critics. The Indian Express critiqued the film for rehashing familiar tropes from previous Karan Johar rom-coms without adding any new sparkle. The review highlighted the film’s lack of depth and reliance on superficial characterizations, stating that it felt like a collection of clichés rather than a fresh narrative.
Similarly, the International Business Times India pointed out the lackluster performances of the lead actors. Ibrahim Ali Khan‘s portrayal of Arjun was described as lacking depth, with his nasal voice and flat expressions failing to convey the necessary emotions. Khushi Kapoor’s performance as Pia was also criticized for bland dialogue delivery and an inability to bring her character to life. The chemistry between the leads was deemed unconvincing, further diminishing the film’s appeal.
Audience Ratings and Controversy
The film’s reception was reflected in its audience ratings. On IMDb, “Nadaaniyan ” holds a score of 4.5/10, indicating a generally unfavorable response from viewers. In an attempt to highlight the positive feedback, a fan account on Instagram shared a screenshot showcasing that almost 75% of users had given the film a 10-star rating. However, this screenshot conspicuously omitted the one-star reviews, presenting a skewed representation of the overall audience sentiment.
Ibrahim Ali Khan re-posted this story on his Instagram, inadvertently drawing attention to the film’s poor ratings. This move sparked discussions on social media platforms, with users questioning the authenticity of the highlighted ratings and the rationale behind sharing such selective data.
Social Media Reactions
The online community was quick to react to both the film and the subsequent rating controversy. On platforms like Reddit and Twitter, users expressed their confusion over the disparity between the purported 75% 10-star ratings and the overall 4.5/10 score. Some questioned the credibility of the ratings, while others criticized the attempt to manipulate public perception.
The incident also reignited discussions about nepotism in Bollywood, with some viewers attributing the film’s shortcomings to the industry’s tendency to favor star kids over more talented outsiders.
The Nepotism Debate
The casting of Ibrahim Ali Khan and Khushi Kapoor, both children of prominent Bollywood figures, has once again brought the nepotism debate to the forefront. Critics argue that the film’s lackluster performances and weak storyline are indicative of a larger issue within the industry, where opportunities are often granted based on lineage rather than merit.
This controversy has sparked conversations about the need for a more inclusive and talent-driven approach in Bollywood, encouraging filmmakers to prioritize skill and potential over familial connections.
Conclusion
“Nadaaniyan ” serves as a case study in the complexities of Bollywood’s star system and the challenges faced by newcomers, especially those with famous surnames. The film’s underwhelming reception highlights the audience’s growing demand for quality content and authentic storytelling.
It also underscores the importance of constructive criticism and the need for emerging actors to hone their craft, irrespective of their backgrounds. As the industry continues to evolve, it remains to be seen how such controversies will shape the future of Bollywood and its approach to nurturing new talent.
